Recently, the writer John Gruber bought a cap online and, in exchange for a discount, handed over his mobile number. Over the next two and a half weeks the company texted him nineteen times. Then he replied STOP, and wrote a short post about it.
Somebody will have been able to show that those texts worked. A proportion of recipients clicked, a proportion of those bought, and the campaign paid for itself several times over. Tactics like this nearly always work, in the narrow sense that produces a chart. What Gruber was describing belongs in the other column, the one nobody fills in. He didn’t just unsubscribe. He came away with a settled view of what kind of company this was, and it wasn’t a flattering one. That view won’t appear in any report. It just sits there, in him and presumably in plenty of others, quietly marking down whatever the brand does next.
In Lady Windermere’s Fan, Oscar Wilde has a character define the cynic as someone who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing. The reply is quoted less often: a sentimentalist sees an absurd value in everything and doesn’t know the market price of any single thing. Most people who work in marketing are far more frightened of the second charge than the first. Nobody has lost their job over a campaign with a good response rate.
Charities understand reputational damage when it arrives as a scandal. Within a fortnight of the Oxfam Haiti story breaking in 2018, around 7,000 people had cancelled their regular gifts. That kind of harm is obvious; it shows up almost at once. The harder question is what happens below the threshold of scandal, where nothing breaks and nobody resigns.
Until the mid-2000s, Which? sold subscriptions with prize draws modelled on the ones Reader’s Digest made famous, and dropped them only after criticism. I don’t doubt they did their job. But consider what was being traded. Which? has essentially one asset: you can trust it when everyone else is trying to sell you something. And there it was, arriving on the doormat dressed as the mailshot you bin unopened. What figure would you put on that?
Then there’s the damage done by omission, which is more common still and even harder to see. The thank-you letter that could have gone to anyone, because it did. The major donor who gives a five-figure sum and hears nothing personal for months. The marathon runner. This spring, people running in London raised more than £87m for charity, a world record for a single day. Many of them spent the winter training in the dark and the spring badgering colleagues for sponsorship. What they often get back is a vest, a template email and, a few weeks later, a request to give again.
None of this is a scandal. It just falls short of what the restaurateur Will Guidara would call reasonable hospitality, let alone the unreasonable kind he built his name on.
Guidara ran Eleven Madison Park in New York when it was named the best restaurant in the world. His argument is that people remember how you made them feel long after they’ve forgotten what you served them, and yet most organisations pour all their ingenuity into the product. One snowy evening, a junior member of his staff overheard a family from Spain saying it was the first time their children had seen snow. When they left, a car was waiting outside with sledges in the back and a flask of hot chocolate, ready to take them to Central Park.
The detail I keep returning to isn’t the sledges. It’s Guidara’s insistence that the idea itself is commonplace. Plenty of people would have the same thought, he says, and then talk themselves out of it because they’re busy. So he created a role he called the Dream Weaver, with no operational duties at all: a person whose entire job was to make it easy for anyone else’s good idea to happen.
Every charity’s supporter care team has someone who has looked at a donation and thought: we should do something for her. The woman giving in memory of her mother. The runner who raised four times her target. The thought is already in the building. What’s usually missing is anyone whose job it is to say yes.
Guidara isn’t sentimental about any of this. The sledges cost money, he points out; there’s no such thing as a free lunch. He’s perfectly happy for people to call it marketing, if that’s what it takes to get the budget, because a family given a story like that will tell it for years. Nobody will ever be able to show you the chart.
—
Fuzzy Logic is a series from Hope, a charity communications and fundraising agency. The series explores the imprecise and uncertain world of branding, marketing, persuasion, fundraising, and allied fields, particularly as they apply to charities, social impact businesses, causes and not-for-profits. Written by Michael Isaacs.
Cause & Effect: Anna Yearley
Anna Yearley is Joint Executive Director of Reprieve, the international human rights charity. Prior... Read more
Cause & Effect: Camilla Knox-Peebles
Camilla Knox-Peebles is Chief Executive of Amref Health Africa UK, the UK office of Africa’s leading health NGO. She... Read more
Thanks for the memories
The procedure required an anaesthetic, William had a reaction to it, but the dentist... Read more